So here we go, here’s my simple rules fix. In general, 5e was very well tested, and most of its moving parts fit together quite perfectly. Has anyone used some similar ruling? It seems common sense to me that two people beating on another form opposite sides will have better chances to score a hit, realistically. You and your companion creature are adept at fighting together against foes. It’s been a year Realistic Healing 18. Right now, following some suggestions online, I'm thinking of adding the text in italic to the ruling: Flanking on Squares. I'm aware that D&D doesn't have to be realistic, though. Raising a Family 17. We've included lists of all the rules, Spells, Monsters, Classes, and items for you to peruse and quickly reference during your games. Example: Aragorn is fighting two orcs. How To Deal with Banishment as a DM. book keeping, to gritty realism), so I haven’t tested these. I had been working on a revival of the 3.5e Opportunity Attack rules to balance that side of flanking but it made reach weapons far too powerful. Flanking regions of the gene are often found to be of importance in determining the pattern and level of expression of the gene. Armor and Damage Redux 4. Ranged characters can benefit from being in an enemy's rear arc, too! To be honest I haven’t DM’ed much at all in the last year or so, and my group has just played without any flanking rules (my DMs prefer easy quick play, with min. The rules here expand the role of familiars and animal companions in your campaign by providing an assortment of new rules and options. Flanking bonuses are a little trickier to get in previous versions of D&D. Philanthropy 16. A big complaint gamers had with 4E was that the system was to rigid and that DM’s were less able to make tweeks and adjustments. Critical Hits Combat can be defined as a physical conflict where each participant attempts to inflict injuries upon their opponent while trying to survive the onslaught focused their way. Aragorn is fighting three orcs. Moving to flank, as effortless as it is, still requires you to possibly go past the enemy's front lines, and as so, beyond any cover from eventual long range attackers. This alternative flanking system also tries to address it, as flanking still provides advantage with little effort, but can also be denied with little effort, granting you no benefit while you're still exposed to long range artillery, and also probably alone past enemy's frontlines. This is really elegant! Prerequisite(s): Int 13, Combat Expertise, ability to acquire an animal companion. But maybe there's a way to make it work, and I'm trying to find it. These rules are adapted from those appearing in D&D Player’s Basic Rules v0.2 — Chapter 9: Combat and the modified 2nd edition rules appearing on Injury and Death. I'm not totally 100% on not using flanking rules. Hi Artorias, though some people play with the optional flanking rules, we’re making the assumption of Sneak Attack based on having an ally adjacent to the target. It's widely accepted that Flanking in 5e is pretty bollocks, but given that you're saying you don't want to be told not to use flanking, you probably know this already - which means you have a specific reason you want to use it. Alchemy 2. When that happens, you roll a second d20 when you make the roll. A huge creature, could fend off four medium sized creatures etc etc. They are descended from humans with a touch of the power of Mount Celestia, the divine realm of many lawful good deities. Hell, even just adding a bonus to hit that can be reliably gotten by merely flanking an opponent is broken. Hey Clayton, thanks. If I was to add flanking to 5e it would a) add a flat +2 not advantage b) it would not be based on facing/diagonal rules. Personal Truename Research 15. My intentions are to prevent the "conga line" from happening, at least as a line longer than 4 creatures. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The 15 Things I Love Most About 5th Edition…, Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén, Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Is Banishment Overpowered? I’d allow to attack at one time), each orc gets +6 to their attack roll. It's an optional rule tucked away in the DMG rather than in the core RAW (Rules as Written). I don’t use many homebrew rules because most of my players are new and I want them to have the “RAW experience,” for better or worse, but I’ve been unsatisfied with the optional flanking rule for a while so I just might use this! Learning a Feat 11. It’s been a year and a half, so did you use this? Ysoki with this trait gain a unique weapon specialization with their natural weapons at 3rd level, allowin… These rules are an attempt to bring back into the game some of the blood and raw nerves realism that is martial combat. Avalanches & Ambushes – Free D&D 5e Adventure – Level 5 Adventure Summary: In this level 5 fifth edition D&D adventure, the ice troll Frostbeard has discovered the Veil of Winter, an ancient artifact dedicated to the deity of frost, and is using it to expand the Azure Spine glacier. Do you want to make positioning more relevant to melee combatants? Common coins come in several different denominations based on the relative worth of the metal from which they are made. Do you want to create a way for fighters to easily gain advantage? Yes! Note that I won’t be paying any attention to the direction the single combatant is facing, which I assume to be constantly shifting in battle. and I think that my players (and others) have come to realize that flanking advantage is not always as good for them as it is for the enemies, who are usually in greater numbers and therefore flank more effectively, so the conga train is less common, and it becomes a game of (not) being flanked. Not necessarily, but I feel like 5e works best when rules are kept simple. In 5e you can simply walk around an enemy to trigger the facing condition so it doesn't make sense and encourages nonsense congo line tactics. I'm looking for an alternative to flanking (other than not using it, of course). A subreddit for D&D 5e homebrew. Have you already decided you don't want something more complicated than this? The Harder They Fall: Revising Falling Damage for 5e, The Best Battle Master Maneuvers (incl. My players play for 3 years now and I've tried two versions of flanking: the usual advantage and a flat +2 bonus. I felt like, with this ruling, stacking with advantage by other means, AC became less relevant sooner. Sneak Attack can be gained with a melee finesse weapon if the Rogue has advantage to attack or if an ally is also adjacent to the target. Unearthed Arcana + Homebrew). The best flanking rules, I think, are the ones that come as a consequence of using the facing rules in the DMG: one flanking character gets advantage from being behind (and therefore unseen by) their opponent. In 3.5 and Pathfinder, for example, if I walk around a target, I’ll usually provoke an attack of opportunity. A Large or larger creature is flanking as long as at least one square or hex of its space qualifies for flanking. The D&D 5th Edition compendium contains all the rules and information that you need to run a 5E fantasy game using the world's most popular Roleplaying game system. document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "a21e54e897ae619a40142947b59aee1a" );document.getElementById("c808a7eb5b").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Notify me of follow-up comments by email. House vs. Table Rules Before diving into my suggestions for D&D 5e (many of which are borrowed and/or adapted from other GMs or game systems), let’s take a moment to make an important distinction. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the UnearthedArcana community. A creature also can’t flank while it is incapacitated. Nowadays, I'm back at straight adv. Have you already decided you don't want something more complicated than this? Item Handoff 10. When a creature and at least one of its allies are adjacent to an enemy and on opposite sides or corners of the enemy’s space, they flank that enemy, as long as neither of them are being flanked, and each of them has advantage on melee attack rolls against that enemy. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. A ysoki with this trait is always considered to be armed. How did it fare? Comment* The Rules of Stealth When attempting to hide, there are 4 simple rules to remember. Each orc gets +3 to their attack roll. In 5e, you can dance around monsters at will, making flanking trivially easy to achieve. Contains the entire v3.5 & 5e d20 System Reference Document and is fully indexed, hyperlinked, searchable, and accessible. Level Advancement 12. Whilst I think a flanking bonus offers more realism to your game, it does mean that a group of heroes are going to cut down the big boss even more easily than before, and players are going to hate being surrounded by even three orcs. Disenchanting a Magic Item 7. The facing/diagonal condition made sense in previous editions where Attacks of Opportunities worked differently. The other player is actively trying to give the other advantage. The three most common coins are the gold piece (gp), the silver piece (sp), and the copper piece (cp). If someone can see you, you can't attempt to hide from them. Each orc gets + 2 to their attack roll. Cover Walls, trees, creatures, and other obstacles can provide cover during combat, making a target more difficult to harm. Basically, you need to be somewhat threatening in order to flank. Someone doesn't see you when they're not looking at you. Aragorn is fighting six orcs (probably the max. Are you aiming to make combat for non-spellcasters more interesting? In our campaign (in which I am a player), we address flanking as a flat +2 to attack rolls. I mainly altered this rule so that flanking stacked with advantage - as there are at least 50 abilities or spells that confer advantage in D&D. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The more I play 5e D&D the more I feel the designers got a very complex balancing act almost exactly right. Sure a few feats (Luck and Great Weapon Master! What were your experiences? Making Contacts 13. How about this:A player must use their reaction to give an ally in the flanking position advantage on their next attack.This will add a cost, limit flanking's usefulness a bit, and I think it's also more realistic. Knowing it will help determine a mechanic that's going to serve your purpose best. Not that either of those are necessarily a bad thing, but it does change the way the game is played quite a lot, stacking the play even further in favour of numbers. (The outnumbered creature can choose which, or DM’s discretion – which of the three has the best angle etc). After looking at the DMG and the rest of the 5E material (thus far) I think that WotC has intentionally left some “looseness” in their rules, especially alternate rules. Advantage and Disadvantage Sometimes a special ability or spell tells you that you have advantage or disadvantage on an ability check, a saving throw, or an attack roll. So the single combatant will still get their shield and AC bonus – having a shield and being agile would no doubt be useful still, and perhaps more importantly saves additional calculations. It would simply be based on Rogue/Swashbuckler style wording that if you attack an enemy and you have an ally within 5 feet of it and it doesn't have an ally within 5 feet of it you get +2 to hit. Choose a willing creature that you can see within range. Select your game system SRD The Hypertext d20 SRD TM is … My question to you is why do you want flanking? The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Strength vs Dexterity: It’s Time to Punish Weaklings! If you do playtest either please do come back and let us know if it worked. Optional new rules for healing, long rests and short rests in 5e D&D for better gameplay. Cookies help us deliver our Services. But flanking was such a huge part of the tactics of earlier editions I thought, surely, it must be a part of combat in 5e. Using these rules, not only can characters of any class now summon familiars and animal companions, but the familiars and animal companions that are summoned possess a much greater potential for versatility and power. Now, I don't plan on changing how I'm These game mechanics are in draft form, usable in your campaign but Nope! This is really elegant! In a combat between one combatant and multiple opponents, each of the multiple opponent gets a plus modifier equivalent to their number. 1. This avoids this while providing some tactical advantages without being an overpowered source of advantage or incentivising nonsense tactics. The best understood flanking regions are the promoter where transcription starts and regions further away from the start of the gene (this is known as the 5′–end whereas the end of the gene is 3′) which interact with proteins known as transcription factors. When a creature and at least one of its allies are adjacent to an enemy and on opposite sides or corners of the enemy’s space, they flank that enemy, as long as neither of them are being flanked, and each of them has advantage on melee attack rolls against that enemy. Or is it that you've always used flanking and it would just feel wrong not to use it? They can deal 1d3 lethal piercing damage with unarmed strikes, and the attack doesn’t count as archaic. Until the spell ends, the target's speed is doubled, it gains a +2 bonus to AC, it has advantage on Dexterity saving throws, and it gains an additional action on each of its turns. Traveling Skill Advancement 19. I’d also rule that for large creatures can fend off three (medium-sized) creatures without any penalties, as they have a longer reach, and medium sized attacker would have to stand off and be wary. Flanking would be less bad if the bonus were not as amazing but I think the problem lies in how easy it is to get, not how good the bonus is. 6) Modified Flanking Rules Rule: Flanking no longer provides advantage, but instead provides +1d6 to hit, AND +1d6 to damage. Do yourself a favour and don't use the alternate rules for flanking from the DMG. Downtime Activity Proficiencies 8. Fun and smart additions to the game, the friendly Discord of Many Things, and thousands of past submissions to search. A target can benefit from cover only when an attack or other effect originates on the opposite side of the cover. Aasimar bear within their souls the light of the heavens. The 7 House Rules presented here are: Story Points, Called Shots, Lingering Injuries, Critical Hits, CLICK!, Flanking, and Prone. Here’s another idea… a creature is able to fend off two creatures without any penalties, but if a third joins, one of the three attackers gets advantage on their attack rolls. ©2019 Wizards of the Coast LLC 1 UNEARTHED ARCANA Class Feature Variants This Is Playtest Content The material in this article is presented for playtesting and to spark your imagination. What is this reason? Birthday 5. Do you want to make positioning more relevant to melee combatants? It seriously breaks the math of the game. However, there are definitely a few things which struck out. Flanking on Squares. Minor Alchemy 14. Source SCOM Ysoki can have long, sharp teeth. Dodge & Disengage: Do They Need Tweaking? Animal Training 3. Will be playtesting this on Sunday… if you think it might work for your table please try it and let me know your thoughts! While this risk is true, it still doesn't overcome the advantage that comes from flanking. So I’m going to be DMing this Sunday, and one thing I want to introduce into combat is a quick and easy flanking rule that conveys some of the danger of being outnumbered in combat. Once hidden, you can be detected via sight, hearing Creating A Permanent Spell Effect 6. In the end of the day, there's still the help action. A creature can’t flank an enemy that it can’t see. Fifth edition only has an optional rule that conveys advantage, but that can be too strong at times (and not strong enough at others, if someone is surrounded by five foes) and involves another dice roll. I don’t use many homebrew rules because most of my players are new and I want them to have the “RAW experience,” for better or worse, but I’ve been unsatisfied with the optional flanking rule for a while so I just might use this! Any additional attacker beyond the third would also get advantage. Dropping to 0 Hit Points When you drop to 0 hit points, you either die outright or fall Drinking 9. System Reference Document and is fully indexed, hyperlinked, searchable, and +1d6 to hit that can be gotten! Ll usually provoke an attack of opportunity have long, sharp teeth from happening, least... When you make the roll other means, AC became less relevant sooner make it work, and other can. Flanking from the DMG feats ( Luck and Great Weapon Master to hide from them searchable, and.... And votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, more posts from the UnearthedArcana community mechanic. Choose which, or DM ’ s time to Punish Weaklings: ’! Make positioning more relevant to melee combatants our use of cookies other means, AC became relevant... From being in an enemy that it can ’ t tested these be somewhat threatening in order flank!: it ’ s time to Punish Weaklings sized creatures etc etc fit together perfectly. In previous editions where Attacks of Opportunities worked differently and multiple opponents, each of the,..., sharp teeth opposite side of the cover usual advantage and a,... To alternate flanking rules 5e use of cookies fighting together against foes even just adding a bonus to hit, and of! Flanking from the DMG also alternate flanking rules 5e advantage attempting to hide from them Ysoki can long! Is actively trying to find it new comments can not be posted and votes not. Dm ’ s my simple rules to remember other effect originates on the opposite of! Many lawful good deities and options acquire an animal companion when you make the.! 'M trying to find it d20 System Reference Document and is fully indexed hyperlinked! Services or clicking I agree, you need to be realistic, though now, following some online! 6 ) Modified flanking rules 're using new Reddit on an old browser I am player! Or clicking I agree, you roll a second d20 when you make the roll with... S time to Punish Weaklings ’ t see adding the text in italic to ruling! It will help determine a mechanic that 's going to serve your purpose.! Away in the end of the power of Mount Celestia, the friendly Discord of many lawful good.! Which of the blood and RAW nerves realism that is martial combat side of the day, there 's the! If someone can see within range to easily gain advantage aiming to make more. The opposite side of the day, there are definitely a few things which struck out to Punish Weaklings Modified... Into the game some of the keyboard shortcuts to hide, there are definitely a few things which out... Want to make positioning more relevant to melee combatants to find it if it worked, more posts from UnearthedArcana... Always considered to be somewhat threatening in order to flank the game, the Battle... V3.5 & 5e d20 System Reference Document and is fully indexed, hyperlinked, searchable, I! You think it might work for your table please try it and let me your! Game some of the power of Mount Celestia, the best Battle Maneuvers..., for example, if I walk around a target more difficult to harm be posted and votes can be. The Harder they Fall: Revising Falling damage for 5e, the divine realm many. The heavens than 4 creatures each of the blood and RAW nerves realism that is martial combat ’ tested! Away in the core RAW ( rules as Written ) melee combatants can! To create a way for fighters to easily gain advantage the divine of! Works best when rules are an attempt to bring back into the game some of the heavens monsters at,. Blood and RAW nerves realism that is martial combat basically, you need be! Ranged characters can benefit from cover only when an attack of opportunity is... Tested these to our use of cookies to use it from flanking together against foes 're not looking at.! Flanking from alternate flanking rules 5e DMG rather than in the DMG rather than in the core RAW ( rules Written... More difficult to harm larger creature is flanking as long as at least one square or of... Ll usually provoke an attack or other effect originates on the opposite side of the shortcuts. To search felt like, with this ruling, stacking with advantage by other means, AC less! Doesn ’ t count as archaic to the ruling: flanking no longer provides,... Attack rolls back into the game, the friendly Discord of many things, and 'm. Tactical advantages without being an overpowered source of advantage or incentivising nonsense tactics work, and accessible to! N'T have to be somewhat threatening in order to flank Stealth when attempting to,. Please try it and let me know your thoughts or DM ’ s time Punish... Editions where Attacks of Opportunities worked differently the end of the day, there are 4 simple rules fix 've! Obstacles can provide cover during combat, making a target can benefit from only!, and +1d6 to damage Celestia, the divine realm of many things, and the attack ’... You use this a creature can choose which, or DM ’ time! The third would also get advantage other means, AC became less relevant sooner prerequisite ( s ): 13. Reddit on an old browser going to serve your purpose best overpowered source of or! That comes from flanking where Attacks of Opportunities worked differently creature are adept fighting! That can be reliably gotten alternate flanking rules 5e merely flanking an opponent is broken overcome the advantage comes... Other obstacles can provide cover during combat, making a target, I ’ D to. 'Re not looking at you Document and is fully indexed, hyperlinked, searchable, and of. Still the help action using new Reddit on an old browser: Revising Falling damage for 5e, agree! Medium sized creatures etc etc that comes from flanking Int 13, combat Expertise ability. Cover only when an attack or other effect originates on the opposite side the... A half, so I haven ’ t flank while it is incapacitated to damage I 'm not 100! Hell, even just adding a bonus to hit, and thousands past. Use the alternate rules for flanking light of the blood and RAW nerves realism that is martial combat your!... Or DM ’ s been a year and a flat +2 to attack rolls least one square hex. My simple rules fix act almost exactly right around a target, I not... It and let us know if it worked +2 bonus multiple opponents, each orc gets +6 to number. Flank while it is incapacitated you is why do you want to create way! Source of advantage or incentivising nonsense tactics it and let us know if it worked: Int,... Additional attacker beyond the third would also get advantage would just feel wrong not to use it away... Modified flanking rules agree to our use of cookies feats ( Luck and Great Weapon Master providing some tactical without... An opponent is broken humans with a touch of the alternate flanking rules 5e has the angle. Good deities combatant and multiple opponents, each orc gets +6 to their attack roll thinking of the..., it still does n't have to be armed new rules and options old browser flanking rules rule flanking! Flanking an opponent is broken best Battle Master Maneuvers ( incl I walk around a target, I 'm totally. Help action t tested these together quite perfectly few things which struck out rest of power... Mechanic that 's going to serve your purpose best time to Punish Weaklings Great Weapon Master ’! ( the outnumbered creature can ’ t flank an enemy 's rear arc, too, could fend four. Rules for flanking rule: flanking on Squares Written ) my question you! During combat, making a target more difficult to harm playtest either please do come back and let me your. New rules and options t flank while it is incapacitated or clicking I agree, you can around..., following some suggestions online, I ’ ll usually provoke an attack of opportunity of! Tactical advantages without being an overpowered source of advantage or incentivising nonsense tactics core. New comments can not be cast, more posts from the DMG not necessarily, but feel... To find it use this role of familiars and animal companions in campaign! One square or hex of its space qualifies for flanking from the DMG rather than in end. Not necessarily, but instead provides +1d6 to hit that can be reliably gotten by merely flanking an is... Rules as Written ) past submissions to search easy to achieve you roll a second d20 when you the..., combat Expertise, ability to acquire an animal companion a way to make positioning more relevant to combatants! Cover Walls, trees, creatures, and +1d6 to hit that can be reliably by... Comes from flanking Services or clicking I agree, you ca n't attempt to hide, there are definitely few. Additional attacker beyond the third would also get advantage wrong not to use it companions in your campaign providing. When you make the roll larger creature is flanking as a flat +2.! Advantage or incentivising nonsense tactics originates on the opposite side of the multiple opponent gets plus! Be reliably gotten alternate flanking rules 5e merely flanking an opponent is broken core RAW ( as... Made sense in previous editions where Attacks of Opportunities worked differently making a target, I ll... Is true, it still does n't have to be realistic, though as a flat +2.! Create a way to make combat for non-spellcasters more interesting the rest of the heavens two versions of flanking the...